Browse Categories

A Merry Dialogue Declaringe the Properties of Shrowde Shrews and Honest Wives Book Cover

A Merry Dialogue Declaringe the Properties of Shrowde Shrews and Honest Wives Book Summary

"A Merry Dialogue Declaringe the Properties of Shrowde Shrews and Honest Wives," published in 1560 by Thomas Rogers, is a fascinating, if somewhat unsettling, glimpse into 16th-century English attitudes towards women and marriage. Presented as a conversation between two men, it's less a narrative and more a collection of observations, anecdotes, and advice – all heavily steeped in the patriarchal norms of the time. While the title itself is a giveaway, the book's tone is surprisingly conversational and attempts a humorous approach to a serious topic: how to identify and manage a 'difficult' wife.
This book is essentially a marital guide, though a very peculiar one. It doesn't offer advice on *being* a good husband, but rather on *diagnosing* wives. The central premise revolves around categorizing women into two types: the 'shrew' (ill-tempered, controlling, and rebellious) and the 'honest wife' (submissive, quiet, and dutiful). The dialogue details the supposed characteristics of each type, offering methods for identifying them before marriage and, crucially, strategies for 'taming' a shrewish wife after the vows are exchanged. It's a window into the anxieties surrounding female agency and the desire for male dominance in Elizabethan society.

The most striking 'lesson' – and one that reveals the book's deeply problematic core – is the belief that a wife’s primary virtue is obedience. The 'honest wife' is praised not for her intelligence, kindness, or ambition, but for her willingness to submit to her husband’s will in all matters. The dialogue repeatedly emphasizes that a woman should be silent, agreeable, and focused solely on domestic duties. This reflects the prevailing social order where women were considered legally and spiritually subordinate to men. The book doesn’t present this as an ideal to *inspire* women towards, but as a natural state they *should* occupy.

Another key idea is the importance of pre-marital investigation. The men in the dialogue spend considerable time discussing how to subtly (and not-so-subtly) assess a potential wife’s character. They suggest questioning her former servants, observing her behavior in public, and even trying to provoke a reaction to gauge her temper. This highlights a pervasive distrust of women and a desire to control their lives even before marriage. It’s a cynical approach, treating potential partners as subjects to be scrutinized rather than individuals to be respected.

The book also offers a rather brutal set of 'corrective' measures for dealing with a shrewish wife. These range from withholding affection and financial support to physical discipline (though the latter is presented with a degree of caution). The underlying assumption is that a wife’s disobedience is a moral failing that must be punished and corrected. This advice is deeply disturbing by modern standards and reflects a culture where domestic violence was often considered acceptable, even necessary, to maintain order. The 'taming' process is framed as a husband exercising his rightful authority, not as abuse.

Finally, the dialogue reveals a significant anxiety about female speech and agency. Shrews are characterized by their 'forwardness' and their willingness to speak their minds, while honest wives are expected to be quiet and reserved. The fear is that a woman who can articulate her own desires and opinions will disrupt the patriarchal order and challenge her husband’s authority. This fear of the 'talking woman' is a recurring theme in literature and social commentary of the period.

  • Readers interested in social history: This book provides a unique and unfiltered look into 16th-century English attitudes towards gender roles and marriage.
  • Students of Elizabethan literature: It's a valuable primary source for understanding the cultural context of plays like *The Taming of the Shrew*.
  • Those fascinated by the evolution of marital expectations: The stark contrast between the advice offered here and modern relationship dynamics is thought-provoking.
  • Readers who can approach historical texts with critical distance: It's crucial to recognize that the views expressed in this book are deeply problematic and do not reflect contemporary values.
Yes, this book sadly still matters today, though not as a guide to emulate. It serves as a stark reminder of the historical roots of gender inequality and the enduring power of patriarchal ideologies. By examining the assumptions and biases embedded in this text, we can better understand the challenges that women have faced throughout history and the ongoing struggle for equality. It highlights how far we've come, but also how easily harmful stereotypes can persist.
Reading on Gutenburg Free reading
Get Paperback Version on Amazon Buy a book
Suggest Book : Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men Book Get on Amazon
“A Merry Dialogue” is a challenging read, not because of its complexity, but because of its deeply ingrained sexism. It’s a valuable historical artifact, but one that should be approached with a critical eye and a firm understanding of its limitations. While it offers a fascinating glimpse into the past, its lessons are best understood as cautionary tales, reminding us of the importance of challenging harmful stereotypes and striving for a more equitable future.
Tags : History - Medieval/The Middle Ages Language & Communication Literature