Browse Categories

Working With the Working Woman Book Cover

Working With the Working Woman Book Summary

"Working With the Working Woman," originally published in 1953, stands as a significant, albeit dated, piece of literature in the field of business psychology and management. Authored by a psychologist and business consultant, the book delves into the motivations, challenges, and management strategies concerning female employees in the workplace during the mid-20th century. It offers insights into the societal norms and expectations of the time, presenting a psychological framework for understanding and supervising women who were increasingly entering the workforce. While its specific advice may seem dated, the underlying exploration of gender dynamics in the workplace remains a fascinating historical document.
The core of "Working With the Working Woman" is its examination of the unique psychological landscape of female workers during an era when women's roles were evolving but still heavily influenced by traditional expectations. The book argues that managing women effectively requires a different approach than managing men, focusing on factors like social relationships, the desire for harmony, and the impact of external societal pressures (like family obligations). It was one of the first mainstream business books to seriously address women as a distinct group of employees, proposing specific strategies derived from psychological principles to improve productivity, morale, and supervision within this demographic. It aimed to provide managers with practical advice tailored to the perceived 'female' work ethic and social needs of the 1950s.

The book introduces several key concepts, though they must be viewed through the lens of their historical context:

The 'Queen Bee' Phenomenon: A central theme is the idea of the 'queen bee' – a woman who, according to the authors, often strives to be the best and brightest in her field, sometimes at the expense of teamwork. This was seen as a common pitfall in supervising successful female employees. The lesson derived was to be aware of this potential competitive streak and to manage accordingly, perhaps by redirecting that drive towards collaborative goals or acknowledging individual achievements within a team framework. (Example: A female sales manager might compete intensely with male counterparts; a manager might need to frame goals as inter-departmental rather than purely individual or gender-based.)

Psychological Motivation and Support: The book heavily emphasizes understanding the psychological needs of female workers. It suggests that job satisfaction and loyalty often stem from feeling valued, having harmonious relationships with colleagues, and receiving recognition for their work. Managers were advised to be more empathetic, provide emotional support, and avoid creating a purely competitive environment that could be detrimental to morale. (Example: A female employee might respond better to a manager who offers encouragement and acknowledges her contributions in a meeting than to one who focuses solely on performance metrics.)

Supervisory Style and Expectations: It advocated for a more nurturing and less autocratic supervisory style when dealing with women. This included setting clear, achievable goals, providing training and development opportunities, and being understanding of personal circumstances that might affect work. There was a focus on creating a supportive atmosphere rather than a purely task-oriented one. (Example: A manager might allow flexible scheduling or be more understanding of time away for appointments, reflecting contemporary but historically specific views on women's 'personal' lives.)

Limitations and Biases: It's crucial to recognize that the book's approach was shaped by the gender biases of its time. It viewed female employment through a lens of 'temporary' or 'secondary' roles for many women, and its strategies often reflected assumptions about women being more relationship-focused and less driven by purely financial rewards compared to men. This perspective is outdated and potentially harmful by modern standards, highlighting the evolution of workplace thinking since the 1950s.

This book is primarily a historical and sociological artifact. It is fit for readers interested in:

  • The history of women in the workplace and the evolution of management thought regarding gender.
  • Understanding the societal context of the mid-20th century, particularly the 'comfortable' integration of women into the workforce before the more radical changes of the 1960s and 1970s.
  • The development of early business psychology and its often naive or biased approaches to sensitive topics like gender.

It is less fit for readers seeking practical, up-to-date advice on managing a diverse workforce today, as its core assumptions and recommendations are largely anachronistic.

Yes, "Working With the Working Woman" still matters, but primarily as a historical document and a cautionary tale. It provides invaluable context for understanding how far workplace thinking has evolved regarding gender, equality, and management strategies. It highlights the biases that were prevalent at the time and how early attempts to 'manage' gender differences in the workplace were often rooted in stereotypes rather than evidence or equity principles. It serves as a stark reminder of how management practices were influenced by societal norms and how far we've come (and sometimes, how far we still need to go) in recognizing diverse motivations and needs among all employees, regardless of gender.
Reading on Gutenburg Free reading
Get Paperback Version on Amazon Buy a book
Suggest Book : Lean In: Women, Work, and the Will to Power by Sheryl Sandberg Book Get on Amazon
"Working With the Working Woman" offers a fascinating, if dated, look into the management philosophies and societal attitudes surrounding female employment in the mid-20th century. While its specific advice and underlying assumptions may seem outdated and even problematic by today's standards, the book remains a valuable historical resource for understanding the journey of women in the workplace and the evolution of management thinking. To explore contemporary perspectives on women in the workplace and modern management challenges related to gender, particularly focusing on overcoming barriers and achieving equality, we recommend reading "Lean In" by Sheryl Sandberg.
Tags : Culture/Civilization/Society Sociology